Overland Park Farmers Market vendor suspended over anti-semitic social media posts

August 25, 2023  |  Staff Report

Pepper Cave was a first-year vendor at the Overland Park Farmers' Market and had been featured in some of the citiy's promotional materials and social media posts earlier this year; photo courtesy of the city of Overland Park

Editor’s note: The following story was first published the Shawnee Mission Post. Click here to read the original story or here to subscribe to the independent Johnson County news source.

Content warning: This story includes hate speech and disturbing language.

[divide]

The Overland Park Farmers’ Market has suspended a first-year vendor after his anti-semitic and hate-filled social media posts emerged.

An Overland Park spokesperson confirmed in an email to the Post that Olathe-based Pepper Cave, owned by Justin Bale, was suspended indefinitely Wednesday apparently in response to complaints the city received about Bale’s social media activity, which in recent days has been filled with blatant anti-semitic invective.

“These posts do not reflect the City’s or the Overland Park Farmers’ Market’s values,” city spokesperson Meg Ralph wrote to the Post. “In fact, this content directly contradicts our strategic goal of being a welcoming and inclusive community and organization.”

RELATED: ‘Market days are work days,’ but all are welcome at OP’s award-winning farmers’ market

Screenshot via Gab

Overland Park is conducting an investigation into the complaint against Pepper Cave as a potential violation of the farmers market’s rules and regulations, which you can find here.

Screenshot via Facebook

“We have reminded all market vendors that the Overland Park Farmers’ Market is an open-minded and inclusive community, and request vendors represent themselves in accordance with market values,” Ralph said.

Pepper Cave seemed to respond on Facebook

Bale shared on social media what appeared to be a response to the farmers market’s suspension of him, saying:

“Thanks for the heads-up! I really do appreciate your professionalism and hard work at the market.

“I’m surprised I lasted this long. For the record they’re literally genociding us. I’m merely trying to ensure the survival of White people.

“They call us ‘goyim’ and believe we only exist to serve them.

“I wish you and the market, and the vendors there nothing but success!”

He closed the message by saying, “Heil Hitler!”

The Post requested comment from Pepper Cave via email but did not get a response at the time this story published. This story will be updated if we receive a response.

Pepper Cave was new to OP Farmers’ Market

Bale started his business officially late last year and joined the Overland Park Farmers’ Market this season as a new vendor.

The farmers market spotlighted Pepper Cave and other new vendors on social media this spring, including pictures of his stand.

Further back, closer to when Pepper Cave was first founded, the company’s Facebook page seemed to focus almost exclusively on the business of selling rubs and sauces as well as the process of growing the peppers for products.

Screenshot via Facebook

Anti-semitic posts became more frequent, brazen

However, in recent days, Pepper Cave’s Facebook page has shifted to openly referencing anti-semitic ideology, including posting a photo of a Johnson County family who practices the Jewish faith standing behind a lit menorah with the caption, “The face of people who try to destroy anyone with an alternative view.”

Another post read: “Being a counter-semite is hard work. Luckily I can screenshot all of the kvetching and it turns into free advertising! Please leave your angry review, Sharon! Bonus points if you’re part of the LMNOP community,” another post said.

Screenshot via Facebook

A Gab account associated with the Pepper Cave has been even more prolific, using anti-semitic slurs and referencing the hate symbol 1488 in a discount code for online sales.

“So some Sharon got butthurt over truth bombs and got me kicked out of our farmers’ market. This means much more time to dedicate to online sales and we can switch the chip recipe to lard! Remember to save 14.88% on all orders with code: GasThejews,” one Gab post said.

Founded in 2016, Gab is a social media site that has grown up in recent years as an alternative to more mainstream sites like Facebook and Twitter, but it has also been criticized for allowing freer rein to hateful and anti-semitic messages.

The company came under scrutiny in 2018 after a man who walked into a Pittsburgh synagogue and shot and killed 11 people posted anti-semitic messages on the site before his rampage.

De Soto-based farm cuts ties with Pepper Cave

Happy Valley Farm, a business based in De Soto, announced on Thursday that it has also cut ties with Pepper Cave.

“We NEVER, EVER had any idea he had these feelings,” Happy Valley Farm wrote. “I worked with him for two years about ten years ago, and NEVER had a single conversation with him that led me in any way to believe he harbored this hatred.”

Read Happy Valley Farm’s full statement on Facebook here.

[divide]

startland-tip-jar

TIP JAR

Did you enjoy this post? Show your support by becoming a member or buying us a coffee.

Tagged , , ,
Featured Business
    Featured Founder

      2023 Startups to Watch

        stats here

        Related Posts on Startland News

        Ready to bet big? Kansas wants to help entrepreneurs win more federal innovation grants

        By Tommy Felts | December 9, 2025

        Kansas innovators now have access to a new tool designed to help them compete for major federal funding. The Kansas Department of Commerce has opened applications for the state’s SBIR and STTR Matching Program, which provides financial support and hands-on guidance for entrepreneurs pursuing federal innovation grants. The matching initiative is part of ACCEL-KS, a…

        New Maker of the Year: Why this mom’s side hustle for the girly girls couldn’t stay at home

        By Tommy Felts | December 9, 2025

        A hobbyist venture that began with making shirts for her kids has earned Julie Swopes a spot on Made in KC’s shelves for her Chiefs- and Royals-inspired tees — along with one of the local-first retailer’s top honors: KC New Maker of the Year for 2025. “I’m just a stay-at-home mom that has turned her…

        Don’t be a stranger: When this Crossroads refuge closes, another chapter begins for Afterword (and the space it leaves behind)

        By Tommy Felts | December 8, 2025

        With two more Open Mic Nights and more than a month left on its lease at Afterword Tavern & Shelves — a cozy corner hotspot where patrons leisurely bond over drinks and good reads — the popular Crossroads third-space isn’t finished telling its story despite losing the space to its new landlord, said Kate Hall.…

        Exporting KC to the world: Esports leader revs come-from-behind global takeover amid World Cup’s big draw

        By Tommy Felts | December 6, 2025

        As the metro bundled up and showed out Friday, getting its latest taste of what the 2026 World Cup has in store, the Kansas City Pioneers dropped new heat — raising the thermostat on their commitment to seize the moment brought forth by the global gathering as a net for esports.  “Now is the time for…